yua

2013-03-18 02:38:02 pm

lol, oops. i accidentally built an old version of mp4box for windows that apparently doesn't respect nonzero initial timestamps on imported streams. so now i get to wrestle with compiling mp4box for windows again, yay.

nate

2013-03-18 06:00:57 pm

ok, the desync with statid under windows bug should be fixed. i've posted a new version of alpha 4 for windows. please check. thanks.

Terribleno

2013-03-18 07:24:08 pm

I encoded 3 qualities of a video with a statID, and there is no desync.

__sdfg

2013-03-19 06:54:15 am

D:

Fixed for me as well.

IsraeliRD

Edit history:

IsraeliRD: 2013-03-19 09:41:12 am

2013-03-19 09:40:13 am

Dragon Power Supreme

Finished encoding my test file on FRAPS and New Master File. Based on previous tests against alpha 2 I got the following results:
- Output files' filesize has increased in all scenarios
- Encoding time is... odd. LQ/HQ/IQ encoding time decreased, MQ encoding time doubled (FRAPS source, not NMS)
- yua crashed (did not invoke mp4box) twice when trying to encode IQ of the New Master File w/ StatID.

Also StatID too small. I cannot fit my full runner name (was able to in alpha 2).

As before find attached ongoing results document. yua alpha 4 in page 4.

Attachment:

EncodingTestResults.doc

nate

2013-03-19 09:59:53 am

do i have this test file? i need to determine why it crashed on iq.

ballofsnow

Edit history:

ballofsnow: 2013-03-19 10:14:50 am

2013-03-19 10:14:20 am

I'll test tonight, but wanted to ask if this is a precursor to video appending? I'm guessing so.

nate

2013-03-19 10:39:13 am

sorry, what is a precursor to video appending? i mean i could have done appending the old way (with the standalone x264 and ffmpeg binaries) too but of course it didn't handle synchronization at all. so now it's going to be something like ... what's the timestamp on the last video or audio frame, whichever is greater ... add that plus one frame in the global timebase to the timestamps of the next segment converted to the global timebase. hopefully that will work anyway.

IsraeliRD

Edit history:

IsraeliRD: 2013-03-20 12:08:02 am

2013-03-20 12:07:14 am

Dragon Power Supreme

Attaching test file torrent (866MBs). Do you want the FRAPS source of it as well?
And note it "crashed" when trying with StatID (meaning it never went to mp4box.exe once it finished). Without StatID it was fine.

Attachment:

ThemeParkInc-Segment01a.7z.torrent

nate

2013-03-20 08:30:58 am

as long as i can reproduce the crash with that i'm good.

ballofsnow

Edit history:

ballofsnow: 2013-03-21 07:36:47 pm

ballofsnow: 2013-03-21 07:34:47 pm

ballofsnow: 2013-03-21 07:33:11 pm

2013-03-21 07:32:25 pm

Finally organized my folder of random source files picked up here over the years. It's not that much in the end. Nate if there's anything interesting in there you want, let me know. Still haven't done much testing yet, will do over the weekend though.

file list

AVC_AAC_720x480i_4x3_2997_YUV420_D4F12D---MarioCHROMABLEED.ts
AVC_AAC_720x480p_16x9_5994_YUV420_D1F23D---KHBBSAqua.M2TS
AVC_AC3_1280x720p_16x9_5994_YUV420_D1F23D---Alex1.M2TS
AVC_AC3_1280x720p_16x9_5994_YUV420_D1F23D---Alex2.M2TS
AVC_AC3_1280x720p_16x9_5994_YUV420_D1F23D---Borderlands1.M2TS
AVC_AC3_720x480i_4x3_2997_YUV420_D1F13D---HasMotionTrail.M2TS
DVSD_PCM_720x480i_4x3_2997_YUV411_D1F13D_megaman.avi
FPS1_PCM_1920x1200p_16x10_6000_RGB_D1F13D---DiabloIII.avi
FPS1_PCM_640x480p_4x3_6000_RGB_D1F13D---Mohaa96KHZ.avi
FPS1_PCM_640x480p_4x3_6000_RGB_D1F13D---MohaaMONOAUDIO.avi
HFYU_PCM_696x456i_4x3_3000_RGB_D1F13D---FZERO.avi
HFYU_PCM_720x480i_4x3_2997_YUV422_D4F12D---Lufia2RAINBOWEFFECT.avi
LAGS_PCM_1024x768p_4x3_6000_YUV422_D1F13D---LaMulanaGOODTESTFORVFR.avi
LAGS_PCM_1920x1080i_16x9_2997_YUV422_D1F13D---GT5.avi
LAGS_PCM_1920x1080i_16x9_2997_YUV422_D1F23D_SplatterhouseXbox360.avi
LAGS_PCM_320x480i_4x3_2997_YUV422_D4F12D---BreathOfFireFLICKERING.avi
LAGS_PCM_512x384p_4x3_6000_RGB_D1F13D---MOHAA.avi
LAGS_PCM_640x480i_4x3_2500_YUV422_D4F12D---LAZeldaGBthroughGameCube.avi
LAGS_PCM_640x480i_4x3_2941_YUV422_D4F12D---Contra3.avi
LAGS_PCM_640x480i_4x3_2997_YUV422_D1F13D---Sonic3D.avi
LAGS_PCM_640x480i_4x3_2997_YUV422_D4F12D---someoldgame.avi
LAGS_PCM_640x480i_4x3_3000_YUV422_D1F13D---KirbyDreamland.avi
LAGS_PCM_640x480p_4x3_3000_YUV422_D1F13D---SmallTextDetailedBackground.avi
LAGS_PCM_640x480i_4x3_3000_YUV422_D4F12D---MegaMan96khz.avi
LAGS_PCM_720x480i_4x3_2997_RGB_D4F12D---SMBonepixel.avi
LAGS_PCM_720x480i_4x3_2997_RGB_D4F12D---SplatterhouseDEFLICKER.avi
LAGS_PCM_720x480i_4x3_2997_YUV422_D4F12D---MarioIsMissing.avi
LAGS_PCM_720x480i_4x3_2997_YUV422_D4F12D---megamanx3.avi
LAGS_PCM_720x480i_4x3_2997_YUV422_D4F12D---WarioLand4GBA.avi
LAGS_PCM_720x480i_4x3_2997_YUV422_D4F12D---ZeldaALTTP.avi
LAGS_PCM_720x480p_16x9_2997_YUV422_D1F23D---Zelda.avi
LAGS_PCM_720x480p_16x9_5994_YUV422_D1F23D---Zelda.avi
LAGS_PCM_720x486i_4x3_2997_YUV422_D1F13D---gt96KHz.avi
LAGS_PCM_720x576i_4x3_2500_RGB_D4F12D---AlexKiddNESonepixel.avi
LAGS_PCM_720x576i_4x3_2500_YUV422_D4F12D---Tombi.avi
MPEG2_AC3_720x480i_4x3_2997_YUV420_D1F13D---MetroidPrime.vob
MPEG2_AC3_720x480i_4x3_2997_YUV420_D1F23D---pso.vob
MPEG2_AC3_720x480i_4x3_2997_YUV420_D1_F1_3D---DMC3.VOB
MPEG2_PCM_352x480i_4x3_2997_YUV420_D1F13D---FZERO.VOB
TSCC_PCM_640x480p_4x3_2000_RGB_D1F13D---Starcraft.avi
ZMBV_PCM_640x480p_4x3_7000_RGB_D1F13D---DOSBOXCAPTURE.avi

Finally organized my folder of random source files picked up here over the years. It's not that much in the end. Nate if there's anything interesting in there you want, let me know. Still haven't done much testing yet, will do over the weekend though.

file list
[hidden]
AVC_AAC_720x480i_4x3_2997_YUV420_D4F12D---MarioCHROMABLEED.ts
AVC_AAC_720x480p_16x9_5994_YUV420_D1F23D---KHBBSAqua.M2TS
AVC_AC3_1280x720p_16x9_5994_YUV420_D1F23D---Alex1.M2TS
AVC_AC3_1280x720p_16x9_5994_YUV420_D1F23D---Alex2.M2TS
AVC_AC3_1280x720p_16x9_5994_YUV420_D1F23D---Borderlands1.M2TS
AVC_AC3_720x480i_4x3_2997_YUV420_D1F13D---HasMotionTrail.M2TS
DVSD_PCM_720x480i_4x3_2997_YUV411_D1F13D_megaman.avi
FPS1_PCM_1920x1200p_16x10_6000_RGB_D1F13D---DiabloIII.avi
FPS1_PCM_640x480p_4x3_6000_RGB_D1F13D---Mohaa96KHZ.avi
FPS1_PCM_640x480p_4x3_6000_RGB_D1F13D---MohaaMONOAUDIO.avi
HFYU_PCM_696x456i_4x3_3000_RGB_D1F13D---FZERO.avi
HFYU_PCM_720x480i_4x3_2997_YUV422_D4F12D---Lufia2RAINBOWEFFECT.avi
LAGS_PCM_1024x768p_4x3_6000_YUV422_D1F13D---LaMulanaGOODTESTFORVFR.avi
LAGS_PCM_1920x1080i_16x9_2997_YUV422_D1F13D---GT5.avi
LAGS_PCM_1920x1080i_16x9_2997_YUV422_D1F23D_SplatterhouseXbox360.avi
LAGS_PCM_320x480i_4x3_2997_YUV422_D4F12D---BreathOfFireFLICKERING.avi
LAGS_PCM_512x384p_4x3_6000_RGB_D1F13D---MOHAA.avi
LAGS_PCM_640x480i_4x3_2500_YUV422_D4F12D---LAZeldaGBthroughGameCube.avi
LAGS_PCM_640x480i_4x3_2941_YUV422_D4F12D---Contra3.avi
LAGS_PCM_640x480i_4x3_2997_YUV422_D1F13D---Sonic3D.avi
LAGS_PCM_640x480i_4x3_2997_YUV422_D4F12D---someoldgame.avi
LAGS_PCM_640x480i_4x3_3000_YUV422_D1F13D---KirbyDreamland.avi
LAGS_PCM_640x480p_4x3_3000_YUV422_D1F13D---SmallTextDetailedBackground.avi
LAGS_PCM_640x480i_4x3_3000_YUV422_D4F12D---MegaMan96khz.avi
LAGS_PCM_720x480i_4x3_2997_RGB_D4F12D---SMBonepixel.avi
LAGS_PCM_720x480i_4x3_2997_RGB_D4F12D---SplatterhouseDEFLICKER.avi
LAGS_PCM_720x480i_4x3_2997_YUV422_D4F12D---MarioIsMissing.avi
LAGS_PCM_720x480i_4x3_2997_YUV422_D4F12D---megamanx3.avi
LAGS_PCM_720x480i_4x3_2997_YUV422_D4F12D---WarioLand4GBA.avi
LAGS_PCM_720x480i_4x3_2997_YUV422_D4F12D---ZeldaALTTP.avi
LAGS_PCM_720x480p_16x9_2997_YUV422_D1F23D---Zelda.avi
LAGS_PCM_720x480p_16x9_5994_YUV422_D1F23D---Zelda.avi
LAGS_PCM_720x486i_4x3_2997_YUV422_D1F13D---gt96KHz.avi
LAGS_PCM_720x576i_4x3_2500_RGB_D4F12D---AlexKiddNESonepixel.avi
LAGS_PCM_720x576i_4x3_2500_YUV422_D4F12D---Tombi.avi
MPEG2_AC3_720x480i_4x3_2997_YUV420_D1F13D---MetroidPrime.vob
MPEG2_AC3_720x480i_4x3_2997_YUV420_D1F23D---pso.vob
MPEG2_AC3_720x480i_4x3_2997_YUV420_D1_F1_3D---DMC3.VOB
MPEG2_PCM_352x480i_4x3_2997_YUV420_D1F13D---FZERO.VOB
TSCC_PCM_640x480p_4x3_2000_RGB_D1F13D---Starcraft.avi
ZMBV_PCM_640x480p_4x3_7000_RGB_D1F13D---DOSBOXCAPTURE.avi
[/hidden]

IsraeliRD

2013-03-21 08:02:29 pm

Dragon Power Supreme

nate, did you receive the file? It says i transferred 303MBs so I'm not sure if you have it.

nate

2013-03-21 09:52:19 pm

haha, cool. i guess i should go ahead and write automation and that tool that dumps info about yua's output in a machine-readable way so we can set up tests.

Quote from IsraeliRD:

nate, did you receive the file? It says i transferred 303MBs so I'm not sure if you have it.

i have 34.9%.

IsraeliRD

2013-03-22 01:54:01 am

Dragon Power Supreme

Yeah it seems to be stuck for some reason. Delete it and replace with a new one attached to this post, maybe it will work.

Attachment:

ThemeParkInc-Segment01a.7z.torrent

nate

2013-03-22 08:29:35 am

i have 100% now. thanks.

__sdfg

2013-03-22 10:52:15 pm

D:

I discovered today that my Droid Razr Maxxckszs isn't smart enough to understand yua's MP4 audio-shifting sorcery when a statID is included. With the stock media player (Google Play whatever), the audio starts immediately rather than after the statID disappears. I tested with videos from both alpha 3 and the updated alpha 4. My phone is running Android 4.0.4. I do not have the same problem if I encode the video and add the statID with anri. Also, the yua videos play correctly in VLC on my PC.

I can post sample videos if you want, but I'm guessing device availability is more of an issue. Unfortunately, I don't have any other Android devices I can test with, so I can't say if this is an Android problem or a Motorola problem.

Android video playback seems to suck, so I don't know how much you want to support, but I thought it might be worth knowing.

Mystery

2013-03-23 06:30:34 am

I could try, if I had a sample (android devices).
But you could also try with another player. Android has a lot of them.

nate

2013-03-23 07:54:55 am

it is definitely worth knowing. problem now is i'm not sure whether it's worth attempting to fix since if it doesn't support initial offsets then does it support noncontinuous timestamps? if it doesn't then the audio is going to be desynced for a lot of output anyway.

unfortunately it's seeming more and more like i'm not through with synchronization yet.

ballofsnow

2013-03-23 01:37:16 pm

Just want to make sure.. is it safe to run multiple instances of Yua?

nate

2013-03-23 01:39:19 pm

should be 100% safe.

ballofsnow

Edit history:

ballofsnow: 2013-03-23 02:19:31 pm

ballofsnow: 2013-03-23 02:04:55 pm

ballofsnow: 2013-03-23 02:03:49 pm

ballofsnow: 2013-03-23 01:52:01 pm

ballofsnow: 2013-03-23 01:51:53 pm

2013-03-23 01:51:09 pm

Neat, yua.video_encoder.log gets written to concurrently.

Well, so far Yua a4 does not like ts/m2ts at all.

nate, if you want to download some stuff, try this sftp. I set it up recently, hopefully it works.
s: pcornell.no-ip.biz
u: sda
p: ESSdeeAY1

ps to everyone, I have limited bandwidth, so don't go downloading if you don't need it.

edit2- I'm going through my clips and putting results in a spreadsheet, but I'll still post some things here as I find them.

Issue: Media Player Classic - Home Cinema 64-bit (1.6.5.6366 (744df1c)) is not respecting audio offset on statid. VLC 2.04 seems to work.

nate

2013-03-23 02:24:33 pm

lol. who knew it would be something other than quicktime 7 that ruined my day.

ballofsnow

Edit history:

ballofsnow: 2013-03-23 02:27:01 pm

2013-03-23 02:26:22 pm

Had I known you were attempting audio offset, I would have advised against it. I've tried it before in the past when looking into StatID mp4 appending without re-encode. Sucks.

nate

2013-03-23 02:28:49 pm

makes me wonder whether it's respecting the initial video offset. the audio and video have their own difficulties. with the audio i don't have a good way to convert the input frame size (which may vary from frame to frame) to the output frame size (which is chosen for me by the codec). seems like the safest way is to just write code to zero-pad both.

ballofsnow

2013-03-23 02:31:00 pm

Yep. At the time that I was trying it, it seemed like the most logical and efficient way of doing things. "Oh, just offset the audio, that should work!! *plays result in media players - some work, most don't* Shit."