My feelings on The Demon Rush
Game Page: http://speeddemosarchive.com/MetroidZeroMission.html
Andrew 'spidey-widey' Brockmann's run
Verifier Responses
Decision: Accept
Reason: It's a minute faster than the current SS, and the verifiers liked it.
Andrew 'spidey-widey' Brockmann's run
Verifier Responses
Quote:
Verifier: so i finished verifying the zm run
Verifier: i'm ambivalent about it, really
Verifier: it's pretty clear the runner wasn't lying when he said that it was rushed
me: yeah I heard there was a sloppy part or two
me: I mean it's only 3 segments
Verifier: yeah, he really should redo it
Verifier: if he doesn't, someone else will beat it eventually
Verifier: not eventually, but soon, even
Verifier: hell, i kinda wanna try :/
Verifier: but that said, accept it. it beats the pants off the old segmented run and still beats the ss by a minute
Verifier: the runner has a bunch of sub-second optimizations and stuff that shows that he knows what he's doing
Verifier: he just didn't take the time to do it properly![Sad](/file/2YUL04TqfmOGn3uc%2F7VlfeIZL5I)
Verifier: i actually took the time to watch the current ss and this one side by side
Verifier: it was instructive
Verifier: since i'd wondered how it could be so much faster with the mistakes it has
Verifier: oh yeah, audio/visual quality was fine, no sign of cheating, etc etc
me: okay fair enough
Verifier: i'm ambivalent about it, really
Verifier: it's pretty clear the runner wasn't lying when he said that it was rushed
me: yeah I heard there was a sloppy part or two
me: I mean it's only 3 segments
Verifier: yeah, he really should redo it
Verifier: if he doesn't, someone else will beat it eventually
Verifier: not eventually, but soon, even
Verifier: hell, i kinda wanna try :/
Verifier: but that said, accept it. it beats the pants off the old segmented run and still beats the ss by a minute
Verifier: the runner has a bunch of sub-second optimizations and stuff that shows that he knows what he's doing
Verifier: he just didn't take the time to do it properly
Verifier: i actually took the time to watch the current ss and this one side by side
Verifier: it was instructive
Verifier: since i'd wondered how it could be so much faster with the mistakes it has
Verifier: oh yeah, audio/visual quality was fine, no sign of cheating, etc etc
me: okay fair enough
Quote:
End time is 27:40. I don't know what the runner was smoking in the bug room about 2-3 minutes into the run but I'm letting it slide. Accepting because it's an improvement to a previously obsoleted category.
Quote:
Video quality is good. No encoding errors I could see.
Run appears to be devoid of cheating, which is always good.
Now, onto the important part. It seems like a great run to me. There were some problems in places (Acid Worm skip and the hives are the most obvious), but most of those are quite difficult anyways and didn't cost that much time. Overall, it seems to be of good quality, and considering it beats the current record, it should be accepted.
Run appears to be devoid of cheating, which is always good.
Now, onto the important part. It seems like a great run to me. There were some problems in places (Acid Worm skip and the hives are the most obvious), but most of those are quite difficult anyways and didn't cost that much time. Overall, it seems to be of good quality, and considering it beats the current record, it should be accepted.
Quote:
Segment 1: Great use of the morph ball for some extra speed. Some problems with the hives, but it didn’t waste much time. Impressive jumping up the corridors. Nice use of the charge beam to kill the enemies as well. Awesome bomb jumping after the power grip is gotten. The room before the Ice Beam was really cool to see. Very impressive segment.
Segment 2: Absolutely awesome Ridley fight. Again, some neat things when backtracking to Brinstar. Little minor fumble in the acid room, wasting about 5 seconds, no biggie though. Epic fight with Kraid too. Nice technique when killing the metroids also.
Segment 3: Decent Mother Brain approach. Really good escape sequence too. Well executed suitless segment. Fairly well done boss too. Good Mecha Ridley fight, great escape.
Accepted. No crippling mistakes, and it seems like it took a good deal of effort.
Segment 2: Absolutely awesome Ridley fight. Again, some neat things when backtracking to Brinstar. Little minor fumble in the acid room, wasting about 5 seconds, no biggie though. Epic fight with Kraid too. Nice technique when killing the metroids also.
Segment 3: Decent Mother Brain approach. Really good escape sequence too. Well executed suitless segment. Fairly well done boss too. Good Mecha Ridley fight, great escape.
Accepted. No crippling mistakes, and it seems like it took a good deal of effort.
Quote:
Here are my comments for the MZM run:
Segment 1--Standard Zero Mission fare here. Got a ton of easy and/or required items and headed to Ridley for some more easy collection. No mistakes here.
Segment 2--Nice and fast through Ridley, minimal time in Kraid, and sped through Tourian. Again, no real mistakes were noticed here.
Segment 3--Mother Brain went perfectly, as did the entire stealth section (I spotted a one second mistake in the middle of it when the runner missed a wall jump, but it was nothing major), and the escape was perfect as well.
Overall--There are no sound/quality issues or cheating, and run is about as ideal as you can get, with minor boss improvements (such as the suit boss and Mecha Ridley. Accept this.
Segment 1--Standard Zero Mission fare here. Got a ton of easy and/or required items and headed to Ridley for some more easy collection. No mistakes here.
Segment 2--Nice and fast through Ridley, minimal time in Kraid, and sped through Tourian. Again, no real mistakes were noticed here.
Segment 3--Mother Brain went perfectly, as did the entire stealth section (I spotted a one second mistake in the middle of it when the runner missed a wall jump, but it was nothing major), and the escape was perfect as well.
Overall--There are no sound/quality issues or cheating, and run is about as ideal as you can get, with minor boss improvements (such as the suit boss and Mecha Ridley. Accept this.
Quote:
found this to be a very impressive speedrun which showcased a nice array of skills and tricks.
There were some mistakes but that's forgiveable considering the long segment lengths.
However, there were some parts where you could save but chose not to. In my opinion, losing one second while saving is better since you can get a better performance afterwards.
I was particularly impressed with the 3rd segment, which you performed really well despite its length and difficulty.
Veredict: Accept
There were some mistakes but that's forgiveable considering the long segment lengths.
However, there were some parts where you could save but chose not to. In my opinion, losing one second while saving is better since you can get a better performance afterwards.
I was particularly impressed with the 3rd segment, which you performed really well despite its length and difficulty.
Veredict: Accept
Decision: Accept
Reason: It's a minute faster than the current SS, and the verifiers liked it.
Thread title: