Ratings?

2005-04-13 08:09:40 pm

Do you know the Muffin Man?

Instead of a "must see list" why don't we just have the ability to rate a movie? That way anyone can see which is the most popular.

Thread title:

alexpenev

2005-04-14 05:21:23 pm

It's probably harder to implement, and nobody likes more work Smiley

I like the idea of some form of rating, though.

Wak

(user is banned)

2005-07-26 08:06:21 pm

you can rate on the archive page, but nobody seems to know / nobody care! that's bad

Trevor

2005-07-26 10:06:33 pm

I'm opposed to any kind of ratings or 'best movies' selections.

look, if you want to know which runs are most popular, just read around on the forums often. Tongue

Lag.Com

2005-07-26 10:59:20 pm

sda loyalist

Ratings are kind of pointless; everyone will like to see runs on games they like. Smiley

Dragoon ZER0

2005-07-27 01:18:40 am

...

I think it would be more interesting to be able to see how many times a record has been beaten since the first video was submitted to SDA.

A simple chart with the previous record holders and their times would show people which runs have had the most competition.

Trevor

Edit history:

Trevor: 2005-07-28 02:57:58 pm

2005-07-27 02:55:53 am

Zelda II: The Adventure of Link
1:31:22 Mike Damiani
1:23:13 Mike Damiani
1:12:10 Scott Kessler

Mega Man X4
100% as Zero
1:03:54 Jonathan Fields
0:58:55 Kevin Wong
0:49:18 Mike Uyama
0:48:29 Mike Uyama
0:47:31 Mike Uyama
100% as X
1:05:05 Steven Brooks
0:51:31 Mike Uyama

The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time
5:25 Mike Damiani
5:04 Mike Damiani
4:57 Mike Damiani (not yet published)

Super Mario 64
16 stars: NTSC
26:01 Brad Cutler
25:17 Mark Korsak
20:56 Ilari Pekkala
19:47 Eddie Taylor
16 stars: PAL
24:33 Stefan van Dijke
24:11 Stefan van Dijke
23:11 Ilari Pekkala
70 stars
1:12:43 David Gibbons
1:01:32 Jacob Cannon

Final Fantasy III
5:37 Peter Tiernan
5:26 Peter Tiernan

The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past
1:51:17 Mike Damiani
1:44:45 Mike Damiani
1:41:26 Alex McIver
1:39:47 Mike Damiani

Super Mario Bros
5:07 Trevor Seguin
5:06 Trevor Seguin

Resident Evil 0
1:59:37 Nolan Pflug
1:45:40 Nolan Pflug

Zelda: The Wind Waker
7:08 David Gibbons
6:42 Mike Damiani

Metroid Prime
pure speed
1:46 Henru Wang
1:35 kip
1:23 kip
1:05 kip
1:04 kip
100%
2:19 Henru Wang
2:10 Nolan Pflug
1:50 Nathan Jahnke
1:37 Nolan Pflug
1:36 kip
1:28 Paul Evans
hard mode
1:32 'Inferno Metroid'
1:24 Benjamin Feng
low%
1:29 Paul Evans
1:18 Robert Nobles
PAL
1:17 'zoidi'
1:15 William Tansley
1:11 William Tansley
PAL 100%
1:58 Besmir Sheqi
1:47 Besmir Sheqi
1:30 William Tansley

[b]Zelda II: The Adventure of Link[/b]
 1:31:22 Mike Damiani
 1:23:13 Mike Damiani
 1:12:10 Scott Kessler

[b]Mega Man X4[/b]
 [i]100% as Zero[/i]
  1:03:54 Jonathan Fields
  0:58:55 Kevin Wong
  0:49:18 Mike Uyama
  0:48:29 Mike Uyama
  0:47:31 Mike Uyama
 [i]100% as X[/i]
  1:05:05 Steven Brooks
  0:51:31 Mike Uyama

[b]The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time[/b]
 5:25 Mike Damiani
 5:04 Mike Damiani
 4:57 Mike Damiani (not yet published)

[b]Super Mario 64[/b]
 [i]16 stars: NTSC[/i]
  26:01 Brad Cutler
  25:17 Mark Korsak
  20:56 Ilari Pekkala
  19:47 Eddie Taylor
 [i]16 stars: PAL[/i]
  24:33 Stefan van Dijke
  24:11 Stefan van Dijke
  23:11 Ilari Pekkala
 [i]70 stars[/i]
  1:12:43 David Gibbons
  1:01:32 Jacob Cannon

[b]Final Fantasy III[/b]
 5:37 Peter Tiernan
 5:26 Peter Tiernan

[b]The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past[/b]
 1:51:17 Mike Damiani
 1:44:45 Mike Damiani
 1:41:26 Alex McIver
 1:39:47 Mike Damiani

[b]Super Mario Bros[/b]
 5:07 Trevor Seguin
 5:06 Trevor Seguin

[b]Resident Evil 0[/b]
 1:59:37 Nolan Pflug 
 1:45:40 Nolan Pflug

[b]Zelda: The Wind Waker[/b]
 7:08 David Gibbons
 6:42 Mike Damiani

[b]Metroid Prime[/b]
 [i]pure speed[/i]
  1:46 Henru Wang
  1:35 kip 
  1:23 kip
  1:05 kip
  1:04 kip
 [i]100%[/i]
  2:19 Henru Wang
  2:10 Nolan Pflug 
  1:50 Nathan Jahnke
  1:37 Nolan Pflug
  1:36 kip
  1:28 Paul Evans
 [i]hard mode[/i]
  1:32 'Inferno Metroid'
  1:24 Benjamin Feng
 [i]low%[/i]
  1:29 Paul Evans
  1:18 Robert Nobles
 [i]PAL[/i]
  1:17 'zoidi'
  1:15 William Tansley
  1:11 William Tansley
 [i]PAL 100%[/i]
  1:58 Besmir Sheqi
  1:47 Besmir Sheqi
  1:30 William Tansley

Cygnus

Edit history:

Cygnus: 2005-07-27 04:20:43 am

2005-07-27 04:02:13 am

Ben Goldberg

You can add 4:57 OOT by TSA, and weren't there a few more SM64 16 star NTSC runs?

Yoshi348

2005-07-27 05:43:37 pm

dinosaur from the past

To say nothing of the various Metroids, although I don't have a clue what the older ones were.

bushwacker

2005-07-27 06:01:05 pm

I love YaBB 1G - SP1!

Well Metroid Prime 100% was at 2:10 or so for a while by Radix, then he did 1:37, then kip had 1:36 without even trying, then finally sparky got 1:28 I guess.

As for any%, I remember kip had 1:22 for the longest time... I think it was Radix who did 1:19, then I'm pretty sure someone else did 1:18 (sorry, can't remember who... if it even happened), then I guess it was 1:04 by kip again.

marshmallow

2005-07-27 06:04:58 pm

Jack of all Trades

All the old, outdated runs can be found on archive.org.

Tub

2005-07-27 06:22:07 pm

m00

except for all the old, outdated runs that were hosted on planetquake, right?

Wak

(user is banned)

Wak

Edit history:

Wak: 2005-07-28 03:26:41 am

2005-07-28 03:26:32 am

you can put the wind waker run by david gibbons (7:08 ) and the newer by TSA, and also the very popular falf life 2 run, as well as every metroid games that i dont know both the ancient and newest best times... for fun, again

Trevor

2005-07-28 02:58:43 pm

revised the list and it looks quite nice.

trihex

2005-07-29 07:19:24 am

Yoshi's eggs are at my mercy!

>_>; This now formatted "who beat who" list seems out of place here. Perhaps Radix could sticky it elsewere. Anyway, that was somewhat entertaining, thanks for the 411.